Should this woman be allowed to live?

I’ve heard of married Pakistani Muslim women having extra-marital affairs and I’ve heard of them killing for love or other reasons, but what Fauzia Sultana has done is truly shocking. A normal woman would never kill her own eight-year old son to avoid giving him to her ex-husband (who demanded custody of the child after divorcing her). Yet she poisoned her eight year-old kid Ali Raza as reported by Dawn.

Her second marriage ended in divorce after two years when she failed to bear a child. Her third husband Tariq Mahmood (father of two sons from a previous marriage) is described by her as a good man who took her to the Holy Land to perform Hajj. One would have thought she’d turn into a truly pious Muslim woman after the Hajj, but this did not happen. She continued her liaison with her lover of 22 years (Mehr Asif) for whom she used to steal jewelry and cash.

Apparently Asif was her lover even before her first marriage. Then she killed her third husband (Tariq) by poisoning him. Why she did it is not known. Maybe he came home earlier one day and found her lover in his house or perhaps he caught her stealing his cash and jewelry. She told everyone that Tariq had died of a heart attack. But then one of her stepsons (Shehzad Tariq) would beat her up (she didn’t say why). Maybe he too suspected her of being immoral. So she and her lover killed the stepson, and she told the cops that some unknown men had killed him. The police, employing their well-known “humane” methods of interrogating suspects, got her to confess to the murders of her husband, her stepson and her own son.

So will she be allowed to live by the state? We know that Pakistanis can get away with murder (after the victims’ near relatives forgive them). If that happens in this case, and she’s not sentenced to death, what about her affair with Mehr Asir? Remember, in Pakistan (and in Islam), the prescribed sentence for a married woman indulging in illicit sex is death by stoning. Will the state decide to kill her? Or will she turn out to have powerful relatives who will save her from execution?


Posted

in

by

Tags:

Comments

14 responses to “Should this woman be allowed to live?”

  1. Shakir Lakhani Avatar

    @ General & Hend: depends on what you mean by justice. In the EU and UK, you can kill a thousand people and yet not be sentenced to death. If this woman had committed the crimes in the EU or the UK, she’d have been judged insane (crazy) and incomepetent to stand trial. In Saudi Arabia, she’d have been killed within a week. In Pakistan at least she’ll have the right to appeal, her case will be studied in detail and if the court decides she’s not sane, she may be committed to a mental asylum (where. I believe, some of Chowrangi’s bloggers-not me-should also be given permanent rooms).

  2. Hend Avatar
    Hend

    Lt.Gen
    Agree 200% with you.

  3. Lt. General Ayub Khan Avatar

    Let the courts deliver justice.

    Chowrangi bloggers are not in moral position to decide how/when human should “live” or not.

    What goes around comes around. What she did is SICK. What she did is immoral. Justice will come her way.

    It always does.

  4. tayab Avatar
    tayab

    Just to add on, it is not for us to decide the punishment, especially the source is news paper clippings. It is upto police to investigate and court to decide.

    Shakir, we do not have any right propose punishment on anyone. Let the competent court decide.

  5. Shakir Lakhani Avatar

    @ Hira Meer: DAWN is a world-class newspaper, there’s no reason why they would fabricate a story like this.

  6. Shakir Lakhani Avatar

    @ Javed: first of all, she may not have been tortured (I only assumed that the police forced her to confess, because that is what usually happens). However, she was under suspicion for killing her stepson only, so why did she confess to the two earlier murders? If her lawyer takes the plea that the confession was under duress, and the court accepts it, she could go free (since, to prove adultery, four male witnesses are needed). That’s why, until today, no man or woman has been sentenced to death by stoning in Pakistan. However, the Taliban did it in the areas they used to control (until the army displaced them).

  7. Javed Avatar

    She is innocent until proven guilty in a court of law – you said your self Shakir “The police, employing their well-known “humane” methods of interrogating suspects, got her to confess to the murders of her husband, her stepson and her own son”. Confession through brutal police methods and trial by media before a fair hearing should not be accepted – even in Pakistan.

  8. Hira Mir Avatar

    This is a legal and police inReported by DAWN. The same dawn who tells us that the encounter made by the brave policeman last week in Islamabad was fake? The same Dawn that from week starting Nov-8 to Nov 14 has everyday headlines about deaths of soldiers and people of Pakistan. I think they are just giving us news that people enjoy thrill. Who is to blame? I think media is to blame. This news has no valid source that the woman killed her child but it is put in Dawn without any confirmation probably just to fill in the slot with some spice.

  9. Hamid Majid Abbasi Avatar

    @shakir
    very stunning………….nd a bit horrifying i would say………nd i m sure she will get exactly what she haz done………..

  10. tayab Avatar
    tayab

    Do we need public opinion to give a verdict on a criminal case? If we do then we ourselves are making a big mistake.
    Our legal and police investigation system should be improved for swift legal proceedings. It mey very well not be a single case of its kind but this event highlights breaking of our social fabric and weakness of legal system.

    We need to give people right of their privacy and when it intereferes with rights of others, then we should trust our legal system (which needs significant improvements).

    Since she is not a public figure, we should not disclose her identity!!!!!11

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *