According to a report in the Urdu daily “Ummat” of 29 June 2009, leading scholars have criticized Junaid Jamshed for declaring Lays chips as “halal”.
Mufti Naeem of Jamaa-e-Binnoria (SITE, Karachi), Mufti Muneebur Rahman (Chairman, Ruet-Hilal Committee), Mufti Abu Bakr (Jaamia Clifton, Karachi) and Mufti Abdul Momin Bangash have declared that having a beard does not make a man an Islamic scholar and Junaid Jamshed (who has not been trained in a madressah) has no knowledge of Islamic jurisprudence.
According to a letter in “The News”, Junaid Jamshed advised students not to study science and technology but to devote all their time to study Islam.
Dr Israr was just repeating the hadith. At the begining sharab was allowed. I dont understand why these dumb witted retards make such a big deal out of a real issue ? They cant stand against the west who malign the Prophet SW but they can get edgy when some one (with even not the intention of hurting others) says about Hazrat Ali ….
@ shahbaz: alcohol was permitted in the early days of Islam, it was made “haraam” later. As for the bible (if you mean the New Testament), it says that Jesus turned water into wine (which means that it is not banned), while in Hinduism (to the best of my knowledge) alcohol is not banned but its consumption is not liked.
@Shahbaz: All the commandments of Islam did not come at once. Everything was revealed one at a time. First was the kalimah, which Prophet Mohammad (S.A.W.) and his Sahabah preached for 13 years. There was no halal/haram at this time. Slowly, through the Holy Quran, Allah SWT revealed more actions that became compulsory (salat, zakat, hajj, etc) and more actions that became haram (alcohol, gambling etc). The Holy Quran was not revealed in one day. Concerning alcohol, many Sahabas drank it and some even had businesses selling alcohol. When the verse banning it was revealed, the streets of Madina were flooded with alcohol. People destroyed all alcoholic bevearages and no one drank it from then on.
@ Yousha , you are the biggest idiot in the world.
Alcohol was never halal . you can see even in bible alcohol is prohibitted . and even in hindu books . How can it be halal.
You are with no common sense .
It was never liked by people with good deeds .You say that Hazrat Ali(A.S) accepted Islam at the age of 8 .if you believe this ,use common sense.
Alcohol was always a favourite beverage of people with no ethics and Hazrat Ali(A.S) is the one who grew up under the shadow of Hazrat Mohammad (S.A.W.W) in the same house
TO SHAKIR LAKHANI
WHO R YOU !!!!! R U AN PROPER ISLAMIC SCHOLAR!!! AAP KABHI KEITHAY HO KAY JUNAID JAMESHED KO ISLAM KA SAHEE NAHI PATA … KABHI ZAKIR NAYEK PAY UNGLI UTTHA THAY HO
AUR KABHI ISRAR AHMED PAY !!!!! JANAB WOH JO KEITHAY HAIN KIA WOH QURAN SE BAHIR BAAT HOTI HAI !!! AAP KAY KAHENAY KA MATLAB HAI KAY YEH SUB FAZOOL BAATIEN KARTAY HAIN!!!! KHUDA KA KHUFF KARO !!!! TABLEEQ PAY AGAR AAP JATAY HO TUO ITS NOT A BIG DEAL !!!! WINE SAHAB PETAY THAY…. YOU HAVE NO RIGHT SHAKIR SAHIB TO SAY ANYONE ANYTHING !!! YOU R A HUMAN BEING SO BEHAVE LIKE AN NORMAL HUMAN BEING !!! MEIN NAY AAP KI POST PHELAY BHI PARI AUR AAB BHI !!!! PHELAY CHUP RAHA LEKIN AAB BAS !!!!AAP HAR EK PAY PIN POINT KARTAY HO
AAP HO KIA !!!! KOI BHARAY ISLAMIC SCHOLAR HO !!!YAN DAYEE HO KOI !!!!KIA HO AAP !!!!KIA HO AAP ? CHALO AGAR ISRAR AHMED KO , JUNAID JAMSHED KO AUR ZAKIR NAYEK KO FOLLOW NA KAREIN TUO SIR AAP KO FOLLOW KARIEN
KIA AP ES QBIL HO !!! AUR JO AAP NAY LIKHA HAI KAY WHO ARE FOLLOW HIM BE CAREFUL TUO I WANT TO SAY THAT
YOU ALSO BE CAREFULL!!! AND WASIE BHI AAP JEISAY LOG HEE LOGON KO GUMRAH KARTAY HAIN !!!!
PLEASE AEISA NA KREIN AAP TUO BEITHAR HOGA
Anyone?
Alcohol was halal until the verse came down prohibiting it. Considering this, why is it an issue if Hazrat Ali drank alcohol when it was allowed.
Ap tableegh per jatay hongay . Sahi or drust ko jannay k liay tableegh per janay ki common sense ki b zaroorat hoti hay bhai sahab.
App ko maloom nahi jo comment Israr ahmed na Hazrat Ali(R.A) k baray mein kahay . aap wo b sunain
and Sahih Bukhari and Ibn e Maja and Saha e Sita ki or books mein b Hazrat Ali(R.A) k baray mein perhein k Hazroor(s.a.w.w) and Sahaba Karam (R.A) unkay baray mein kia kehtay hein and what your fool Israr ahmed said .He is fitna for muslims.He has just created anger .Israr ahmed ya uskay walid sahab jo b hein unhon na shayad kabhi sharaab pi ho gee but Humara yeh emaan ha k Hazrat Ali(R.A) jaisi shaksiat kabhi aisa kaam nahi ker sakti. Ager aap Saha E sita ki books ko nahi mantay to phir Allah aap ko hidayat day. And Kabhi Surah Ahzaab ki Ayat 33 ki tafseer b parhain lakin wo nahi jo Israr ahmed na banai ho bulkay jo Mutafik ho. Phir usko b na manain aap to aap ka Allah hafiz
@ Shahbaz: agreed, Dr. Israr is only a doctor with a medical degree. He only pretends to be an Islamic scholar, and those who follow him should be careful.
and please aesi mails mujhe aap send na karna aainda kay baad