Case of Farah Hameed Dogar: What is the big deal?

Arthur Conan Doyle was decorated with the prestigious title of “Sir” for creating a fictitious mystery solving character viz. Sherlock Holmes and both of them have become legend. We in Pakistan, have no such title for detectives or mystery solving professionals. However, highly qualified journalists like Dr. Shahid Masood, advocate Naeem Bokhari and Ansar Abbasi who have the guts, courage and will to keep on informing people, though media , about the misdeeds of some very honorablea as well powerful judges and Chief justices and likes of them. The nation has acknowledged their endeavors with great applause and admiration.

Latest is the case of Farah Hameed Dogar daughter of none other than the CJ of Pakistan Supreme Court Abdul Hameed Dogar. The only sin of the ambitious poor baby was to appeal for and get just 21 plus marks to enabling her to become a future human serving Pakistani lady Doctor or a specialist in a vast field of this sacred profession. She adopted the normal procedure realizing the fact that being the daughter of a sitting CJ there will be no obstacle in achieving her innocent ambition, as such there are already hundreds of thousand such student who got extra marks enabling them to get admission in different universities, either due the courtesy of their parents holding elite position in government institutions or parliament or having bags full of bucks.

Unfortunately she was ignorant that Mr. Ansar Abbasi was around who smelled the golden opportunity to make a big news out of it, knowing the fact that similar allegations were made by advocate Bokhari against the son of CJ Chaudary. While the advocate was humiliated by his own community, the CJ lost his job and made a hero by lawyers.

There is no denying in appreciating the good work done by Ansar Abbasi, but in his zealot to expose the CJ Dogar of having undue advantage of his position, he forgot to look into the other side of the script. People would like him to expose all those institutions where degrees and grace marks are sold to the bidders. Isn’t it a crime to be mute over countless similar cases? Why to select Farah Dogar? What is the big deal? Are we heading toward turmoil like that of CJ Chaudary? This has not happened something afresh.

In 1993 I met a guy in Karachi who possessed a Master’s Degree and Gold Meddle in Economics from a university without attending a single class and by virtue of that he jumped from the status of a clerk to the seventeen grade officer in a prestigious financial institution. Similarly LLB and other degrees are available in Karachi at affordable price. These institutions and their highly educated personals are responsible for selling degrees and enhancing marks thus producing undeserving professionals of future. Mr. Ansar Abbasi may visit any examination hall during exams and, being an honest outspoken journalist, apprise of the nation of the actual scenario taking place there. Before commencing the exam, papers are out for sale to the sons of elites. In some places you will see examinees placing arms no their desks to frighten and scare invigilators in order to use unfair means of copying from books or material imported from outside the examination hall.

We need to expose the people involved in this gruesome business of destroying our talent and providing opportunities to the undeserving students to capture very highly responsible portfolios in future, which has placed us in the present predicament in all segments of life. Without their eradication every endeavor to streamline the working of all the institutions will be a frivolous exercise. We have to change the entire system if we want to put our nation on the track of progress and prosperity. To expose the mischief of Farah Dogar may prove to be the first drop of rain, but at the moment it is not a big deal, we have to catch all dirty fishes and throw them out of the pond to clean it up once for ever.


Posted

in

by

Tags:

Comments

22 responses to “Case of Farah Hameed Dogar: What is the big deal?”

  1. Mohammad Yusha Avatar

    Have you never cheated in an exam or a test? Never copied homework from a friend? If the answer is yes, which I’m 100% sure it is, you have broken the law and should be punished. Please hand yourself over.

  2. Mohammad Yusha Avatar

    You sound as though this is the first time someone has been caught and as though she has commited something so serious that she should be hanged. It is not the first time it has happened, and certainly not the last. People should leave the poor girl alone, and look in their own ‘girebaan’.

  3. Imran Ahmed Avatar
    Imran Ahmed

    Dear M. Yusha
    I fail to see any logic in the stance that if we are “mute over countless similar cases” we should gloss over Justice Dogar’s crime. To me it is as ridiculous as saying that if the police cannot catch all the thieves in the country it should not even try to catch the robber robbing in front of everyone.
    No one, least of all people living in the public eye, should be above the law. All of us are agreed that law has been broken and a crime has been committed. Why should we not punish a criminal just because we cannot catch all the criminals all at once? Please try to convince me because this chain of thought is making no sense to me.

  4. Mohammad Yusha Avatar

    Is there a single one of us who can honestly say that he/she has never cheated in a test, an exam, never copied homework from a friend or has never gone to a teacher asking for his/her marks to be increased. Even toppers who get 95% go to teachers to have it converted to 98%. Even toppers are not satisfied, so what right does the average person (read:average cheater) have to point fingers at this girl. Even a saint should not, unless he has pointed his finger at every single one of the millions who have cheated in tests and exams and have copied homework from friends and have benefitted from generous teachers. The only people creating a fuss out of this case, if it is a case, are those idiots who are so shameless that they, while knowing just how much they have benefitted from friends in homeworks, tests and exams, are not hesitant in indulging in this kind of disgusting hypocrisy. The reason why I think Ambreen has done a much better job than Fahd writing on this topic is because she had the courage to tell reality as it is. Fourth Paragraph:…in his zealot to expose the CJ Dogar of having undue advantage of his position, he forgot to look into the other side of the script. People would like him to expose all those institutions where degrees and grace marks are sold to the bidders. Isn’t it a crime to be mute over countless similar cases? Why to select Farah Dogar?

  5. Hassan Avatar
    Hassan

    I just want to say that our leader “ASIF ALI ZARDARI” is currept man. He is not a brave man. He can’t run the country. His team is very very weak.

  6. Shakir Lakhani Avatar

    @Yusha: Bill Clinton faced impeachment not because he indulged in extramarital sex (which is very common in his country), but because he did not tell the truth. Our leaders, judges and politicians have to be models of integrity, and even if thousands of students have benefited from unfairly awarded grace marks, in the case of Dogar’s daughter, an example has to be made, so that in future anyone who tries to break the law will know that he or she can be punished for it.

  7. Mohammad Yusha Avatar

    You seemed to have missed the point of my comment

  8. Imran Ahmed Avatar
    Imran Ahmed

    Good article. The big deal Mr Yusha, (you seem to have missed the point of the article and the sarcasm) is that the elite who lead by example have to be more honest than the rest of us.
    The judiciary should be scrutinized far more rigorously for integrity because we have given it the job of dispensing justice to the country’s citizens. If we cannot trust our judges to be fair the state edifice starts to totter.
    One of the most important pillars of society is Justice. The progress of a society depends on a justice system that is universally applied without exception and is immediate in execution. The other two important factors for progress are a a government that is accepted by its people as being representative of them and that responds to the will of its people.
    Coming back to judges – a judges reputation was said to be as important as that of Caesar’s wife. Not only should a judge be virtuous but he /she should be above suspicion.

  9. Mohammad Yusha Avatar

    Very well written, Ambreen! Fabulous stuff! I agree with every word. Finally, some one has shown some common sense and I am more than glad. I never understood what he big deal was about that girl in the first place when this kind of stuff happens all the time. I mean, why pick on one person. Thank you for this magnificent piece of work.

  10. Kashif H Avatar
    Kashif H

    We lack leadership. The irony of the matter is that we always lacked it by since Quaid’s demise. In the third world nations or developing ones its the vision of leadership that steers the country to new heights. We are a lot of imitating imbeciles. I know for a fact that when Nawaz Sharef was around all high govt officers and ministers wore shalwar qammez and a waiste coat, tried talking in the same tone and became fond of food, mercedez, cricket and Muree. Likewise in Gen Musharaf’s time we know what these cronies liked! on the same note if their is an honest dedicated upright person as president this country will develop by leaps and bounds. I assure you this at any given day.

    We need social justice and security. All this moneky biz will end in a fortnight. The criminal is a coward. The sinner remains scared. It takes one candle to lighten up the entire room.

    May Allah help us find the right person and that would be first drop of rain!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *