Why are Muslims so cruel to animals?

Why are Muslims so cruel to animals? What does a Muslim do when he sees a dog? He picks up a stone and throws it at the poor creature. I once owned a salt works in the coastal area of Karachi. There was plenty of wild life there in 1978, but a few years later, most of it had disappeared. I remember large lizards (more than three feet in length) and colored snakes, all which had been wiped out by humans before 1991 (when I left the salt trade).

One day I came across a worker trying to kill a chameleon. “Why do you want to kill it? What harm has he done to you?” I asked. “Why does he keep changing colors?” the man retorted. I managed to convince him not to kill the poor creature, but I know that the minute I left the place, he went ahead and killed it anyway. Back in 2003, when I went to live in Block 5 of Clifton, a couple of dogs in the street outside the apartment complex became very friendly with me. They would accompany us whenever I and my wife went for a walk. Maybe they thought I cared about animals because apparently I was the only one who hadn’t tried to hit them with stones. The watchmen at the gate would be appalled when they saw me petting the dogs (who, according to their primitive way of thinking, are unclean creatures). A few days later, the dogs disappeared. Someone had shot the dogs, said the guards. I am fairly certain it was one of them.

I know there is a Hadith about angels staying away from houses where dogs are kept, but no one knew this when I was growing up. We had a couple of dogs, as well as exotic birds and peacocks (which we kept in a large cage). And I knew many other families who also kept dogs as pets. I have also heard another Hadith about a prostitute going straight to heaven because she fed a hungry dog, but apparently this one is ignored by Muslims. In Saudi Arabia, the only dog I saw was one being taken for a walk by an American (in Jeddah). In practically all countries where Muslims live, no one cares for animals.


Posted

in

by

Comments

47 responses to “Why are Muslims so cruel to animals?”

  1. Momina Avatar

    @SL: The lizards you are mentioning now are not 3 feet long. they are those little ones (but so freaky). The Geckos.

    The kuffaar Quraysh had planned to murder the Messenger of Allah s.a.w.w. But Allah SWT protected the Prophet s.a.w.w. and he left Makkah. But the kuffaar did not stop chasing him (s.a.w.w.). Abu Bakr r.a. was also accompanying Muhammad s.a.w.w.

    When the kuffaar’s danger was nearby they decided to hide in a cave. Oh! i forgot the main thing. it was the lizards who were helping the kuffaar in locating Rasool Allah s.a.w.w.

    After entering the cave some pigeons (i think or maybe doves) laid eggs over a web that a spider (or many) had quickly woven (by Allah SWt’s Command) giving the image of cave that hadn’t been entered for a long time by any human being.

    Another story goes in the times of Prophet Sulayman a.s. where he and his army were hiding from the army of his enemy in the woods. As we all know, One of Prophet Sulayman’s miracles was being able to talk to animals. He communicated with them so all the animals tried to distract the enemies when they were looking for Prophet Sulayman a.s. and his army EXCEPT for the lizard which was using its tail (gross!) to point towards the places where Sulayman a.s. and his army went.

    Another story, when Prophet Ibrahim a.s. was to be burned alive all animals were trying somehow to kill the fire while the lizard was blowing on it to flare it up.

    The Prophet s.a.w.w. ordered to kill the Wazagh (lizard), and said; “It blew in the fire of Abraham.” [Al bukhari 3359, Muslim 2237, An-nasai 2888 and Ibn majah 3228]

    There is another hadith about the killing of the lizards:

    Prophet Muhammad (PBHU) said: Who kills a lizard in one stroke gets 100 hasana, and who kills it in the second stroke gets 70 hasana.

    Also, the Prophet s.a.w.w. called them noxious creatures (reported by Aishah r.a.).

    Anyway, they are dangerous (poisonous) as well. Its great if one can kill it. But they are so freakishly scary looking…i have had the worst incidents of my life with these geckos…euwwwww!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  2. Lt. General Ayub Khan Avatar

    Shakir Saab, this story about the lizard is interesting. How come I never heard about it?

    Can you find out the name of the legend for me.

    cheers

  3. Lt. General Ayub Khan Avatar

    That is just a myth. 99% Pakistanis dont kill lizards even when they are inside the house on the walls, which is often the case. They are our friends, they kill any insect that dares to enter the house. Win-win situation.

    I don’t think Muslims are cruel to animals. In moderate countries like Turkey and Malaysia for example, dogs and pets are like family. I have 2 dogs and they are domestic. Those lucky bastards get treated better than my guests! I have spoiled them rotten I think.

    In less developed neighbourhoods in Lahore and Peshawar, I see sometimes the boys are throwing pebbles at the dogs. Just do what I do — just chastize them lightly but also tell them why what they are doing is WRONG WRONG WRONG.

    It really goes down to culture and upbringing. I don’t think it’s a religious issue. Islam in all its power CONDEMNS any mistreatment of Allah’s creations — whether it’s a dog or a whale or a platypus!

    incidentally, dogs are better creatures than human beings are. At least they don’t backstab eachother, lie, and kill all the time. Dog is man’s best friend. So are animals.

    Co-existence my friends!!!! Therein lies a broader message for humans which we still fail to fathom, alas.

  4. Sam sall Avatar

    That’s so racist ,just because you saw individuals cruel to animal you acusethe whole Muslim nation of being cruel.you know there many crimes and mistakes done by other nations and you never find us picking mistakes or talking badly about them.Islamic culture and guidance is always instruct its follower to be nice to animal trees and the rest of God creatures. One the well known stories is the one about the prostitute who god forgave her and rewarded her with heven when she gave a very thirsty dog some water. Also that story when the prophet change the plan he put to his troop to enter Mecca when he found a dog geving birth on his troop way ,so he asked his people to take another road and not to disturb the dog.

  5. Shakir Lakhani Avatar

    @ confused Indian: Pakistani Muslims used to kill lizards because it was a lizard who revealed the whereabouts of some illustrious Muslim to his enemies (I don’t remember the name of the man, it certainly wasn’t Aurangzeb).

  6. Momina Avatar

    @JKS: Yes but i would never feel safe around any dogs. I don’t run away when i see them. its just i wouldn’t feel very comfortable petting and tickling them.

    We have the same risk with cats but they are not very feorcious in nature and their paw scratches can be tolerated unlike a dog’s bite. A friend was bit on her ear by her dog. Bad mood day. She had to get stitches done for it.

    My kitten has had many bad mood days but the scratches are not so dangerous. (I just LOVE cats and kittens!!)

    My Uncle coaxed me into patting his dog (Beaglish kind). I did and the poor dog was so sweet but my morbid dread just intensified. The heavy panting and the sinew strength that i could feel did not have a calming effect on me.

    I am happy with cats and birds. The male pheasant does become violent in his yearly cycle but it is just a bird after all…

  7. haider Avatar
    haider

    what exactly made u say that muslims are cruel to animals?

  8. James Killian Spratt Avatar

    @ Momina: The dogs you describe as very dangerous, as the one who tore the woman’s face off, are called “pit bulls,” and are peculiar in their unpredictability. Other types that can be quirky are Dobermans and Rottweilers, both big types used for guarding. Most other types, including them, if treated well by humans, are very agreeable as companions.

    The huge hue-and-cry in the States about pit bulls started, oddly, about 100 meters from my old studio in Stone Mountain, Georgia, when sometime in 1980 or so several of them escaped my neighbor’s enclosure and killed a couple of small children nearby. Strangely, he still had several pitbulls penned up when I lived there some years later. One must be careful around trained attack dogs; pit bulls remain controversial.

    Most strange dogs will give you a chance if you squat to their level and extend your hand so they can smell it. If they have not been abused by your type before they will advance and sniff, recording your unique odor as a “friendly,” and never regard you with suspicion again. As with people, if you greet them properly, you can make a friend.

    There are wild black bears living within a mile or two of me, and this in what you might call well developed neighborhoods. We would only shoot if they try to come in the house, which I’ve never heard of one doing. They are very shy of humans, unless you confront a mother bear with a cub, then watch out. My friend Ray has one nearby that he guesses weighs 600 lb. and stands 6 feet tall on its hind legs; but he’s on the edge of a wilderness area. Ha, when I go visit him I have to blow the horn to get the herd of wild whitetail deer to get out of the road.

  9. confused indian Avatar
    confused indian

    very insightful indeed,

    Lakhani saab, in childhood on pretext of our muslim friend we used to stone poor chamaeleon. reason for it that they were responsible for Aurangzeb’s defeat at the hands of Shivaji!

    when Aurangzeb was hiding in well it was chamaeleon sitting on top of well who told Shivaji about Aurangzeb’s whereabouts.

    nice story! sadly we believe it, and kill so many innocent chamaeleons. now i regret that.

  10. Shakir Lakhani Avatar

    @ Yoo Shoo: we had to keep the birds in a cage so they wouldn’t escape and be killed by predators. If this is cruelty, so is keeping animals in a zoo. I meant physical cruelty, like beating animals with sticks (like men beating women to get jinns out of their bodies).

Leave a Reply to Lt. General Ayub Khan Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *