Changing names to improve health

The people of Pakistan and India are very superstitious, perhaps because of the high poverty and illiteracy in the two countries. I have met many people who think a black cat crossing your path means that you will probably have a very bad day. As for superstitions about the solar and lunar eclipses, the less said the better. Normally, women who belong to superstitious families are not allowed to go out of their houses unless they require urgent immediate medical treatment. When there is a solar or lunar eclipse, even a woman who is in a critical condition is locked up even if she’s in danger of dying.

But there is one piece of superstition which I can’t understand. Why do some mullahs and scholars advise people to change the names of children who’re not well or who’re hyperactive? I remember a little girl years ago (the daughter of distant relatives) whose name was changed so that she’d get better. Of course the name change had no effect on her health. Then there was a certain scholar associated with the Binnoria mosque in Karachi who advised his followers not to give the name “Aasia” to their daughters. He said families who named their daughters Aasia were always unlucky.

I wonder if those who regularly comment on black magic can say something about changing names to make people lucky or healthy.


Posted

in

by

Tags:

Comments

30 responses to “Changing names to improve health”

  1. Shakir Lakhani Avatar

    MADdie: in the 1960s, during the movement to divide Bombay Presidency into Maharashtra and Gujrat, the Gujratis of Bombay (Mumbai) had to face terrible hardships, including seeing their daughters stripped naked and made to parade on the streets in the nude (this kind of thing still happens in both India and Pakistan). Nowadays, that mad guy Thackeray and his son are deadly against “outsiders” living in Mumbai. Do you think he’s crazy enough to stip some “outside” people naked, as heppened in the sixties?

  2. James Killian Spratt Avatar

    Ni, how ma, chingus, und previet! Cher-cher, nannun saengak dass wir sollen dans la meme patois mariah, or it will be vieles anstrengende Arbeit zu fabyao woda nidjen. Eo eosso un poco a li a oulta haath, kurigo chokum an einander auf seeda haath, kurundeh yo soy nykulturni bestimmt im jenem except English, et kugot naui fault dans Wirklichkeit annimnida. Und vous auch, the same; nos sind geboren odi uri sommes nee, y nostra elterne nidjennen have learned, quando nos zu kleine meilleur savoir.

    Don’t worry, Mr. Moderator; there are no dirty words in there. The world’s a great place, isn’t it? Igijigidra!

  3. MADdie Avatar
    MADdie

    Well I know a couple of words and phrases in Tamil:

    The first Tamil phrase that I learnt was to say “Naa Oneye Kaadlikerein”…it stands for ‘I love you’ in Tamil…thats because my first girl-friend (although can’t really say that I was her bf too) was a Tamilian.

    And then I learnt a few swear words in Tamil…thats becasue she rejected my proposal for a Tamil guy!!!

    Even I’ve been born and brought-up in Mumbai…so willingly or un-willingly I had to learn to read, write and speak Marathi from the 3rd grade onwards….

  4. Hend Avatar
    Hend

    mahdi i can understand marathi since i grew up in mumbai and i love it..specially the literature and old movies in marathi…i dont understand tamil though…do you speak it?

  5. MADdie Avatar
    MADdie

    Hey guys, gujarati is not my lang too but its sweet and sometimes fun to read/listen.

    Once in a while is not bad huh?

    Wonder if anyone will understand if I start writing marathi…or tamil!!!!

  6. Hend Avatar
    Hend

    shakir
    i prefer english too as i dont really speak gujarati that well. it is not my language.

  7. Shakir Lakhani Avatar

    Hend: I would prefer to stick to English, it doesn’t seem fair to the others on this blog, probably none of whom knows Gujrati. Re. your views on the Pune incident, let’s wait until I or someone else writes a post on it. Cheers.

  8. Hend Avatar
    Hend

    shakir bhai

    chaalo tame betting karochho ki kona haath chhe aa kaam ma? tamara maanas ke amaara manas? mane to e JuD ni saazish lage chhe…bija koi nahi. pan india govt e kaam nu blame IM par daalse otherwise thackerey nu point prove thai jase

  9. Shakir Lakhani Avatar

    Hend: I did want to write on the Pune incident, but thought it better to wait until something concrete turned up.

  10. Hend Avatar
    Hend

    shakir bhai

    shoo thayoo tamne?

    no headline picked up from times of india! no taking pot shots at india! no branding hindus as superstitious

    marethee kai gustakhi thayee to muaf karjo…pan apda kaam chaaloo raakho

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *