A fatwa to end all fatwas

veiled working womanDuring and after my recent angioplasty in hospital, I was surrounded by cheerful female nurses and both male and female doctors. In fact, the angioplasty was carried out under the supervision of a confident and smartly dressed female cardiologist (who is head of the cardiac unit in one of the city’s major hospitals).

Suddenly, on my fourth day at the hospital, I almost died of shock when I woke up to find a tall, slim woman doctor completely covered in black from head to toe (with only a slit for the eyes to see), peering at my semi-naked body. I thought I had passed away and gone to some place where all virgins are dressed like that. Then she introduced herself. I wanted to ask her what the hell she was doing, touching the body of a male patient, when women dressed like her should not come within five feet of a male stranger. Mercifully, the male doctor who was her boss sensed how I felt and asked her to leave.

I refer to this incident because the Deobandi Ulema in India have issued a fatwa to end all fatwas: “Women should not work alongside men, and if they do, they should be completely veiled”. I didn’t know there were people like that in India, but apparently there are.

With women advancing in every field, and Pakistan itself having female army officers and air force pilots, here are some nuts trying to attract attention to themselves by issuing strange edicts which everyone will ignore.

I won’t say much, except that when you force half the population to look like black ninjas, you can’t progress at all.


Posted

in

,

by

Tags:

Comments

29 responses to “A fatwa to end all fatwas”

  1. Amna Zaman Avatar

    @shakir. I believe that women should be free to do as they wish. Veil is not an obligation. We are still stuck in these things and the world is like progressing at a very fast pace.

  2. b minhas Avatar
    b minhas

    if it is because of free will that they wear burqa then why no lady of ANY other religion wears it? simple question gives clear answer.

  3. Shakir Lakhani Avatar

    @ Amna Zaman: I really don’t understand what you’re saying. Being a woman, you should have a better perspective on this subject. If a woman wears the niqab (a burqa with only a slit for the eyes to see the outside world), shouldn’t she also observe the other tenets of the Taliban interpretation of Islam? The Taliban say there’s no need for a woman to venture out of her house, etc. Why do such women get a university education? And if a woman doctor wants to wear the niqab, and still wants to practice, shouldn’t she attend to female patients only?

  4. Shakir Lakhani Avatar

    @ Tayyab: the burqa is compulsory in Saudi Arabia, Iran and those parts of Pakistan which are under Taliban control. Why do these men force their women to dress like this? I doubt whether there is a single woman in the whole wide world who willingly adopts this dress (unless she’s ugly or doesn’t want to be recognized when she’s out having fun with her boyfriend!).

  5. Amna Zaman Avatar

    @tayab. I would not agree with shakir as well. You cant really impose your will on others. And this has been happening for so long in our country. We need to change this mindset I believe because this will not take us anywhere but even back in the stoneages.

  6. tayab Avatar
    tayab

    Shakir. Now you are imposing your will on others. As long it is not mandatory or forced it should be left on individuals. I dont like it, you dont like it as many others but do not force your opinion on other.

    I know many people would to dress that way, let it be. Where will it end? No one can wear a tie or cap or lungi. It is rather shamful that we are trying to force or desires and judgement on others. As long as it is not compulsory, I am OK with it.

  7. Shakir Lakhani Avatar

    Tayab: there is no individual choice where burqa is concerned. I have seen Saudi and Iranian women throw their burqas and abayas away the minute they land in London. Women are forced by their husbands or their families or even their culture to wear the degrading dress. Some of them (like my son’s wife) actually believe that the abaya is compulsory for Muslim women, even though the hot climate makes them sweat and stink. But then, women are more easily brainwashed than men.

  8. tayab Avatar
    tayab

    This dress code is not obligated by religion so it can not be linked with Islam. If it is an individual’s own choice then we have no right to object to it.

  9. Amna Zaman Avatar

    perverted religious leaders giving fatwa for suicide bombing have no knowledge about the religion as well as the world. Why listen to them? The youth must be protected from these leaders before they ruin our country and kneel down the economy even more.

  10. Yasir Qadeer Avatar
    Yasir Qadeer

    I agree with the author that when women are progressing as much as men in all fields of life then why we should restrict their dynamic involvement. This shows that this extremist values are fast taking a global shape. Women have every right to progress and utilize their potential. We must think about this from a rational and liberal mind.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *